Theory Roadnewbusiness@theoryroad.com(866) 3-THEORYGet in touch

Marketing Agency RFP Template: Sections, Scoring Table and Pitch Rules.

Most agency RFPs ask fifty questions and still fail to tell agencies the budget, the goal or how they will be judged. This template fixes that. Copy the sections, fill in the brackets, and score every response on the same weighted table.

By November 18, 202613 min read

Want this done for you?See our full-service marketingget a free plan

A marketing agency RFP (request for proposal) is the document a company sends to a shortlist of agencies to describe its business, goals, scope, budget and timeline, and to ask for written proposals it can compare on the same criteria. A good agency RFP template makes those comparisons fair: every agency answers the same questions, knows the budget, and is scored on published weights. This page gives you a complete template you can copy, a weighted scoring table, and the pitch etiquette that keeps good agencies in your process.

It is written for marketing leaders and procurement teams running a review for paid media, SEO, creative, a lead agency or a full roster. Fill in the bracketed fields, delete what does not apply, and send the same document to every agency.

Before you write the RFP.

Three decisions make the RFP easier to write and easier to answer. First, decide what you are hiring for: a lead agency, a channel specialist, or support for an in-house team. Our guide to in-house team vs agency helps with that split. Second, agree the budget range internally. Third, agree who scores responses and who makes the final decision.

Keep the field small. The ANA and 4A's 10 principles of pitching recommend a long list of 8 to 12 agencies for the RFP, and say inviting more agencies does not make a better pitch. They suggest 2 to 3 months for a US review and 3 to 4 months for a global one. If you only need basic screening, send a short request for information (RFI) first. The same principles say an RFI should be a simple screening tool, not a detailed audit.

The RFP template, section by section.

Copy each section below into your document. Bracketed items are yours to fill in.

RFP template: timeline, required responses and terms.

Sections 5 to 8 tell agencies when to answer, what to answer, and the commercial, legal and security terms they will be held to. Putting terms in the RFP saves weeks of negotiation with a finalist who cannot accept them.

Evaluation criteria and scoring table.

Publish the criteria and weights in the RFP. Each scorer rates each agency 1 to 5 on every criterion independently, before any group discussion. Multiply by the weight and add up. The weights below are a starting point. Adjust them to what matters most for your scope, and keep the total at 100.

Agency RFP scoring table (weights total 100)
CriterionWeightWhat a 5 looks likeWhat a 1 looks like
Understanding of our business and goals15Restates the goal in business terms and challenges a weak assumptionGeneric capabilities deck with our name added
Proposed approach and plan20Specific first 90 days, priorities ranked, clear asks of our teamLists every service they offer
Measurement and reporting15Reports from our source of truth, defines every metric, tests incrementalityPlatform-reported metrics only
Relevant experience and references15Similar problems solved, references willing to talkNo comparable work or references
Named team and seniority15Senior lead named with real time allocation and a light account loadTeam to be confirmed after signing
Fees and commercial transparency10Full breakdown, no hidden markups, fees tied to scopeSingle number with no assumptions
Terms, data ownership and security10Accepts client ownership of all accounts and data, clear security answersAccounts in agency name, vague security answers

A worked example: an agency scoring 4 on approach (4 x 20 = 80), 5 on measurement (5 x 15 = 75) and 3 on everything else (3 x 65 = 195) totals 350 out of a possible 500. Compare totals, then discuss the criteria where scorers disagree by two points or more. Our free agency scorecard runs a similar evaluation.

Pitch process etiquette: paid pitches, spec work and feedback.

How you run the process decides which agencies take part. The best ones decline reviews that look expensive and unfair. The ANA and 4A's principles cover the main points.

  • Be transparent. Share the purpose of the review, goals, KPIs, and whether the incumbent is pitching.
  • Limit spec work. If speculative creative or strategy work is needed, the principles say the marketer should provide a clear brief, scope and budget for the request.
  • Pay finalists for real work. The principles describe finalist stipends as a sign of good faith and call for compensation and IP terms to be negotiated jointly.
  • Respect ownership of pitch work. The 4A's guidance on ownership of pitch work says clients should not request or require ownership unless prepared to pay the agency fairly for the rights, and that a participation stipend does not by itself transfer ownership.
  • Keep to the timeline. Set firm dates and agree any change with every agency.
  • Make time for chemistry. Include the people who will make the decision and the people who will do the work.
  • Stop when you have decided. End the process as soon as the right partner is clear.
  • Give feedback to everyone. Tell every finalist why they did or did not win.

What enterprise buyers should require.

For larger companies, make sure the RFP and the final contract cover these points. They map to sections 6 to 8 of the template.

  • Procurement. Supplier onboarding requirements, insurance, payment terms and billing entity stated in the RFP so finalists can confirm them.
  • MSA plus SOW. Legal terms in a master services agreement and scope in statements of work, with written change orders.
  • Data access and account ownership. Every account, data set and creative file owned by the client, with agencies as users.
  • Security and privacy review. Written answers to section 8, reviewed by your security team before contract.
  • Reporting cadence. Monthly performance reporting and quarterly business reviews against agreed definitions.
  • Named senior team. Senior lead and core team named in the SOW, with approval rights over replacements.
  • Exit terms. Notice period, handover obligations and removal of access defined before signing.

Where Theory Road fits.

Theory Road is an operator-led growth firm based in Liberty Hill, in the Austin area, working with companies across the US. We build and run our own portfolio of brands with our own money, and senior people do the work. We respond to RFPs for paid media, SEO and AI search, and we contract on an MSA with a statement of work. The client owns every account and data set. A clear RFP with a budget range is the fastest way to find out if we are a fit.

We are not a fit for reviews that require unpaid spec creative with ownership transferred, global media buying across many countries, or a large on-site team. If we sound like a fit, send us your RFP.

What should a marketing agency RFP include?

Company background, scope of work, goals and KPIs, budget disclosure, timeline, required responses, evaluation criteria with weights, legal and MSA terms, and data, security and privacy questions. Send the same document to every agency.

How many agencies should we send an RFP to?

The ANA and 4A's recommend a long list of 8 to 12 agencies for an RFP, narrowed to a few finalists. Inviting more agencies does not produce better proposals and raises the cost for everyone.

Should we disclose our budget in an agency RFP?

Yes. Without a budget, each agency sizes its proposal on a guess and the responses cannot be compared. A range for working media and for agency fees is enough.

How long should an agency review take?

The ANA and 4A's suggest 2 to 3 months for a US review and 3 to 4 months for a global one, with firm deadlines agreed with every participating agency.

Should we pay agencies to pitch?

If you ask for speculative work, yes. The ANA and 4A's principles describe finalist stipends as a sign of good faith, and 4A's guidance says clients should not require ownership of pitch work unless they pay fairly for the rights.

How do we score agency proposals fairly?

Publish weighted criteria in the RFP, have each scorer rate every agency 1 to 5 on each criterion independently, multiply by the weights, and then discuss only the criteria where scorers disagree.

Get in touch

Let’s talk.

Tell us what you sell and what you want more of. Email newbusiness@theoryroad.com or use the form, and a senior strategist will be in touch.

Tell us about your business.

A senior strategist reads your inquiry personally.

Rather email? newbusiness@theoryroad.com or call (866) 3-THEORY.

Thanks. We have it.

A senior strategist will be in touch by email or phone.